
My girlfriend Shelley recently came out of the Atheist closet to the world, including members of her family, friends and co-workers. I am proud of her for many reasons, one being that she sent out e-mails to family members detailing her journey and what she discovered along the way. She also made an official announcement on the Facebook. Secondly, I am proud of her for coming out at all. Many people without faith remain in the closet about their beliefs because there can be real life repercussions to being an out and open Atheist. However there has been a recent movement in the Atheist community with billboards and bus ads letting people know that they are not alone in their disbelief. As a result many people have been bravely stepping outside their closets and finding that it's not so bad out in the open air. For this reason as well as a few more Shelley made her announcement to the world and I think that's pretty swell to say the least.
Shelley was kind enough to share with me the many responses she got to her coming out and I noticed a similar trend that I also experienced when coming out. One crowd was totally behind her, however there was another crowd that gave two lines of negative responses.
The first was the "Have you considered ______?" This response seems as if some people can't possibly imagine what a life without a god would entail. They think that we will be lost without SOME sort of spiritual system guiding us even though we have outright told them that we are happy if not excited about our discoveries. They then offer us some small sect of a religion (or a larger one) to reconsider or for that matter some set of woo woo beliefs which have no more evidence in favor of them than religions do. Shelley was recently offered Buddhism. I have been offered various forms of deism and astrology among other woo woo alternatives.
The second response actually offends me a little. It is the "This is just a phase/stop on the journey" response. It's a way of calling us immature, dumb, unenlightened. It assumes that we'll be back, that we'll come to our senses one day and realize that god exists (their god in particular). This response may be the result of poor listening skills. Atheism for us is not a stop in the journey. It might just be the destination. That response treats atheism like a it's just a fad. Big jeans were a fad. Talking like Napoleon Dynamite was a fad. Tights-as-pants were/are a fad (trust me...tights are not pants). My atheism has taken years of study and thought to cultivate. It is a lifestyle, not a fad.
Shelley heard the "You can always return to Christianity when you're ready" response from a few people after she came out. And my own parents, the most liberal awesome parents ever, have said to me upon occasion, "You were born a Jew and you will die a Jew" as well as "Judaism will be here when you're ready for it." On the first point they're kind of right. I will always be a cultural jew. I will always retain a part of that culture (mostly the food) in my life but I have no place in my life for a god that I don't believe in and a set of laws that are outdated (and in many cases plain wrong). On the second point...I give a third finger salute. To an extent my parents believe that they have failed me when I talk of my Atheism and I have to remind them that Jews fought for millenia for their right to believe what they want to believe. This includes not believing and I am thankful for the opportunity to make that decision on my own.
This post is not telling people to shut up. I don't have the right to NOT be offended. I fortunately live in the country where I DO have the right to believe or not believe what I want (so long as I don't physically hurt people because of those beliefs) and to express those beliefs no matter how offensive they may be. That includes me being offended by your beliefs. In the end Atheism is just another idea on the marketplace of ideas. Neither Atheism or Theism deserves any special privileges in the marketplace. Nor do my politics, my hairdo, or my tattoos. I'm realizing now that this post is actually about WHY these kind of responses are ultimately unsuccessful. To be more specific...

Response #1 ("Have you considered _____?") doesn't work because, yes, we have in fact considered many options (outside of what we were indoctrinated with as children) and we're not necessarily going to be willing to delve into one more of the many possible religions and sects and woo woo beliefs that abound. This is especially true if you can't provide solid evidence based on scientific standards. Theists around the world have discounted thousands of gods and goddesses without the bat of an eyelash. We just believe in one less god than you do...AND we have given it a lot of thought. Daily thought. And discussion. And study.
Response #2 ("This is just a phase/stop on the journey) doesn't work because not only are you calling us stupid but once again you're also not backing it up with anything. You can call me an idiot all you want but if you can't back it up with solid evidence for why my idea is wrong (and I'm not talking about anecdotal, "I was an Atheist and then I found _____" arguments) then your argument will have the effect of merely alienating your audience.
So in the end Theists can still use these tactics when someone comes out of the closet about their Atheism. They will most likely not work, but fire away. I'm sure that I will be having these conversations until the day I die and I welcome that. Finding out what is actually true about the world is extremely important to me and it is through study, experimentation, conversation and debate that we will find the truth. In the meantime I'm going to open up one of the tiny champagne bottles in the back of my refrigerator and give a toast to the girl that I love.



